UPDATE: President Donald Trump signed an executive order today, directing government agencies to keep undocumented families together as they are detained crossing the border.
As the nation slowly learns more about the Trump administration’s policy of separating families crossing the border and placing children in immigration detention centers, a few leading voices in the real estate industry have spoken out.
Multiple news outlets have documented the horrors inside these detention centers, including families warehoused in cages or inside of a former Walmart and children reportedly being mocked while they cry after being separated from their families. Data obtained by MSNBC’s Chris Hayes shows that 91 percent of parents being forcibly separated from their children at the border are being prosecuted for misdemeanor crimes.
Glenn Kelman
Inman reached out to 10 companies, leaders in the real estate industry and box stores to see if they had any comment or formal policy in support of or condemning the actions. Only Redfin CEO Glenn Kelman, a previous vocal proponent of legal immigration, voiced his thoughts in response and condemned the policy. Zillow directed Inman to a tweet from Amy Bohutinsky, the chief operating officer of Zillow Group.
“The mission of everyone in our industry is to help families move to a better life, and this is what immigrant families are now trying to do,” Kelman said. “Many of Redfin’s customers are immigrants. It is how virtually every family came to America.”
“Reasonable people can disagree about how many immigrants to accept in the U.S. and how to enforce our laws against adults, but children are sacred; they should not be harmed,” he added.
“We understand the argument that some immigrants have broken the law, and that adults arrested for a crime are usually incarcerated separately from children, but the consequences of this approach, however logical, are unbearable. We cannot act as if others have done this when this has been done in our name, through a democratic process, as the will of our people. Each of us has to tell our congresspeople and our president to stop it.”
Airbnb’s co-founders Brian Chesky, Joe Gebbia and Nathan Blecharczyk released a joint statement on Twitter, condemning the actions.
Ripping children from their parents’ arms is cruel. This policy must end. pic.twitter.com/R2b3FXtxqU
— Brian Chesky (@bchesky) June 18, 2018
Bohutinsky also condemned the separation of families at the border in a statement on Twitter.
“I can’t help thinking that if my dad — who was a 9-year-old immigrant — was separated or lost from his parents, how differently his life and mine would have turned out,” she posted. “We are better than this.”
At Inman Connect New York in January, Bohutinsky told the story of how her father and grandparents immigrated to the U.S. and embraced the American dream. She also noted that the dream hasn’t always been available equally to everyone, particularly blacks and Hispanics.
Amy Bohutinsky
Kelman has not shied away from confrontational political issues that weren’t explicitly related to housing in the past. He opened up about navigating the policies of President Donald Trump at Inman Connect New York in January. In his statement on the separation of families at the border, he continued by saying the industry’s larger obligation is take a stand for the American Dream.
“It has given our country its moral stature and dynamism,” he added. “It is understood by the most humble people, in the most forgotten parts of the world. It has drawn the most ambitious and daring people to our country. We’ll always be debating how to balance fulfilling that dream for our own citizens and for those who seek to come here, but we should never, ever give it up, no matter the cost.”
Re/Max and Lennar did not respond to a request for comment. Both Keller Williams and Compass told Inman they were unable to get comment from executives within a 24-hour time frame due to travel schedules.
HomeServices of America declined to comment. The National Association of Realtors (NAR) told Inman this is not a topic it has weighed in on before, and it has no formal policy.
Neither Target nor the Sears Holding Corporation – which owns Kmart – responded to a request for comment on the use of a former Walmart as a detention center and if they would allow the federal government to use one of their former stores.
NAR in particular has a political lobbying arm, where it leverages donations from members to support candidates for political office. It recently waded into political waters by removing Congressman Dana Rohrabacher from its “President’s Circle” club of top donation recipients after he expressed lack of support for fair housing protections for LGBTQ individuals.
This story was updated after publication.
